I have the noodie, jockey and pico packers. my favorite has to be the pico as it's a lot smaller, looks more natural on me (I'm 5,3). it definitely is a lot harder to pee with as it's small, it is like a mini jockey imo.
I have been using the Noodie for a few weeks now and I've tried dozens of STP's. The Noodie is amazing, I haven't had any accidents with it. It is really soft so it condenses in your pants. Its size is perfect for shorter guys like myself (5"1). I also purchased a realistic packer for daily use (size 3in) and it is truly the best daily packer I've had. It is definitely very affordable and worth every penny!
This STP packer is really good in attention to detail. Just a minor thing that's kind of annoying is it gets dirty easily. And its hard to get hair, dust, and things that stick to it off. There are other company's I have bought a STP packer from and their textured silicone is non stick. Which is why I gave this a 4 out of 5 but overrall I love it.